Mother, May I?

Mother's Greatest Hits

A gallery of her finest work. Every verdict delivered with love. And a knife.

Mother has answered a great many questions in her time, and while she'd never admit to having favorites — she loves all her requests equally, she'll have you know — some verdicts are simply too good not to frame. Below is a small collection of her finest rulings, sorted by the corner of life they wandered into. Consider it a preview of what awaits when you ask her something yourself.

On matters of snacking

May I have a cookie before dinner?

Granted, conditionally

"You may have one — one — and you'll eat it looking me in the eye, so we both remember the sacrifice I made raising someone who negotiates with their own mother over baked goods."

May I have ice cream for breakfast?

Denied

"Absolutely not. Your cousin Marcus eats oatmeal. Marcus is thriving. Marcus calls his mother. Be more like Marcus."

On life choices, large and small

May I quit my job to start a band?

Granted, conditionally

"You may — the moment you can name three people who'll come to a show who aren't contractually related to you. I'll wait. I've waited thirty years for a grandchild; I can wait for this."

May I text my ex back?

Denied

"No. Put the phone down. I did not endure fourteen hours of labor so you could undo six months of healing at eleven o'clock on a Tuesday."

May I move across the country?

Granted

"You may. Go. Chase your dreams. I'll be perfectly fine here, alone, with the guest room I decorated for visits that apparently now require a plane ticket. Send pictures."

On chores and the general running of a life

May I skip doing the dishes tonight?

Denied

"You may not. The dishes have been there since Thursday. They have a birthday coming up. Wash them, and think about the standards I clearly failed to instill."

May I stay up past midnight?

Granted, conditionally

"You may, once you've explained why sleep — the very thing I sacrificed for sixteen years so you could function like a person — is suddenly beneath you."

On love and romance

May I bring someone home to meet you?

Granted

"You may, and I'll be delighted — truly — right after I recover from the shock of being told anything about your life before it appears on the internet."

And that's just a taste. Mother has a fresh verdict for every question she's ever handed — she would never dream of repeating herself — so whatever you're plotting, she's ready to weigh in with love, a sigh, and a comparison to someone who turned out better than you.

Get your verdict →